Getty Images
DC’s lawyer basic has sued 14 of the town’s largest landlord companies, claiming they entered into agreements with a property administration software agency to preserve rent costs excessive in a metropolis with a housing affordability disaster.
The criticism, filed earlier immediately by Attorney General Brian Schwalb, focuses on the multifamily landlords’ use of software from Texas-based agency RealPage, which suggests rental costs primarily based on a pricing algorithm. Key to these fashions, in accordance to the go well with, is the information fed in from the landlords and the stress RealPage places on them to stick to the code-derived rental charges.
“RealPage and the defendant landlords illegally colluded to artificially elevate rents by taking part in a centralized, anticompetitive scheme, inflicting District residents to pay tens of millions of {dollars} above truthful market costs,” Schwalb stated in a launch tied to the criticism.
The collaboration “quantities to a District-wide housing cartel,” Schwalb stated, noting that “nicely over” 30 % of buildings with 5 or extra models use RealPage’s software, together with 60 % of 50-unit-plus buildings. Across a wider Washington-Arlington-Alexandria space, greater than 90 % of models in giant buildings are topic to RealPage pricing, in accordance to Schwalb’s workplace.
RealPage’s rent administration service, YieldStar, has come beneath rising scrutiny in recent times. RealPage and the property administration companies using their software have been the topic of a class-action go well with filed within the Southern District of California in October 2022, alleging the “cartel” of artificially inflating costs. The Department of Justice’s Antitrust Division opened an investigation in November 2022 into RealPage’s position in potential landlord collusion.
ProPublica’s investigation in October 2022, which seemingly incited authorized motion, famous that YieldStar discourages direct bargaining with renters and may advocate landlords settle for decrease occupancy charges reasonably than take decrease rents. A developer who labored on YieldStar’s algorithm advised ProPublica that rental leasing brokers had “an excessive amount of empathy” in contrast to the software’s pricing techniques. Its creation of “work teams” of would-be rival landlords may additionally invite antitrust scrutiny, a former federal prosecutor advised ProPublica.
Ars contacted RealPage and defendant Greystar Management Services for remark and can replace the submit with any new info.
In response to ProPublica’s reporting, a RealPage consultant stated the agency used “aggregated market information from a wide range of sources in a legally compliant method.” The consultant additionally advised that with out RealPage, landlords usually conduct telephone checks of rivals’ costs, whereas RealPage can “prioritize a property’s personal inner provide/demand dynamics over exterior elements akin to rivals’ rents.”
Schwalb’s DC lawsuit cites a former “high-ranking supervisor” at Greystar Management Services, one of many RealPage clients named within the go well with, as confirming that landlords used rent administration software to collude and lift costs. “He responded that in fact they did—it is all the purpose landlords used the software,” in accordance to the criticism.
The criticism additionally cites inner and public statements by defendant landlords relating to their robust alignment with RealPage pricing. A slide from an inner Greystar presentation cited within the criticism advised that “no less than 95 %” of RealPage costs needs to be used, as “(*14*) of utilizing income administration elevated extra constant outcomes.” Former Greystar staff allegedly advised the Attorney General’s workplace that negotiating rents exterior RealPage steering was “unacceptable.”