Last winter, I discovered myself at a cocktail party in the metropolis. It was a combined crowd, by which I imply individuals who understood my work, those that didn’t, or those that have been skeptical of it. I’m a crypto lawyer and coverage advocate, so I’m used to questions like: Are you a lawyer for Bitcoin? And do you even use a financial institution?
As everyone knows, the crypto trade had been rocked at the finish of 2022, which meant I fielded extra questions than normal. At one level, a buddy pulled me apart and requested, “Is this the end of crypto? Are you okay?”
Now, a yr later, I can reply with confidence: Not solely was it not the finish, however 2023 was additionally truly good for crypto. I’m extra dedicated to this area than ever, and going into 2024, I’m assured that the know-how will persist — that crypto is right here to remain — even in the face of repeated destructive press, continued naysayers, and protracted international regulatory strain.
The optimist’s case for crypto is easy: Technical maturity is happening in tandem with regulatory headway and wider adoption.
But to be an optimist in crypto is definitely to be a realist, to acknowledge not solely the thrilling developments we see getting into 2024, but additionally the challenges we should take head-on in the yr forward. I name this strategy “crypto optimist realism”: an acknowledgment of each how far we now have come and the way far we now have to go.
Even if 2023 exceeded the expectations of optimists like myself, it doesn’t imply that 2024 will probably be a cakewalk. In truth, in the three points that matter most to crypto — technical development, regulatory progress, and adoption — the tailwinds taking us into 2024 will probably be met with continued headwinds we should overcome to progress right into a mature trade.
The know-how superior quicker than anybody imagined. Now we have to present why that issues.
In the wake of centralized “crypto-in-name-only” monetary collapses, 2023 bore out a vitalized recommitment to advancing sustainable, hardened, decentralized networks. The know-how, throughout diversified networks, is lastly attending to a spot that may deftly deal with what “normies” would anticipate from the web itself, whether or not or not it’s for monetary, social, communication/messaging, or informational purposes.
Last yr, the trade obsessed over zero-knowledge know-how, zkEVMs, and scaling options, rightly so. Massive technological leaps got here to life at scale, defying the expectations of many who believed that if such know-how have been attainable exterior of mathematical theorems, it wouldn’t be attainable for many years.
Across practically any vertical you possibly can think about, some factor of blockchain has begun to seem.
There are actually quicker, extra inexpensive, and extra environment friendly methods to transact and work together on the web, secured by decentralized databases hosted by computer systems globally that permit people to protect and management their very own information, worth, and content material. The present state of blockchain positively seems like one thing out of “Neuromancer.”
But right here we’re, dwelling it.
Now the problem is guaranteeing that hundreds of thousands of folks worldwide can stay this future, too.
The first chasm to cross is the way to discuss accessibly about what blockchains truly do and why they’re higher, at the least for sure use circumstances, than what we now have now. The use of insider phrases (“rollups,” “smart contracts,” “oracles”) with the conventional world is usually counterproductive. Jargon makes the tech and the trade esoteric, isolationist, and inaccessible. So a lot of the lexicon related to blockchain developed for a small, developer viewers, which suggests to develop alongside the increasing attain of the tech, we should change how we speak about it, too.
With some tech challenges nicely on their approach to being solved at scale, a main hurdle stays to make the why of blockchain higher understood.
This means explaining how the know-how offers actual, tangible advantages in a way simply grasped on a world foundation and throughout techies, normies, and industries.
“Regulatory clarity” superior in surprising methods, however the AML quicksand requires an answer
For these of us participating on coverage issues, the finish of 2022 was existential. It was laborious to fathom how regulators and policymakers may have interaction meaningfully after the trade writ massive had been plastered with integrity points that arose from the downfalls of companies that shall not be named (and that you recognize nicely by now). Much to my nice shock, final yr noticed important engagement by policymakers round the globe on crypto issues, in many optimistic methods I couldn’t have anticipated. Globally, 2023 noticed:
- Japanese lawmakers revealed a “Cool Japan” whitepaper in April. It proposed a regulation for decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs — one other phrase to make accessible!) as methods for much less related cities and communities to be engaged with the authorities and divulge heart’s contents to non-yen-backed stablecoin (with stringent stablecoin regulation)
- The EU formally handed and commenced implementing the Markets in Crypto-Assets regulation (MiCA). A primary-of-its-kind complete laws targeted on centralized companies and repair suppliers in the crypto area, MiCA units out stringent necessities for crypto companies in the EU whereas additionally permitting for continued innovation on the tech aspect.
- The U.Okay.’s Treasury Department issued a complete proposal for crypto regulation.
- In France, policymakers started fascinated about frameworks for decentralized finance (DeFi), taking the know-how critically sufficient to contemplate laws that received’t stifle innovation whereas additionally defending customers and preserving market integrity.
- Hong Kong and the UAE created crypto licensing regimes for centralized crypto companies and repair suppliers, together with — in Hong Kong — a brand new proposed regime for issuance of stablecoins.
- In the U.S., two main items of proposed laws, the Financial Innovation and Technology for the twenty first Century Act (FIT Act) and the Clarity for Payment Stablecoins Act, made their manner out of the House Financial Services Committee in a bipartisan method, with potential preparations to maneuver to the House ground in 2024. And final June, the U.S. House Committee on Energy and Commerce carried out a significant listening to on nonfinancial use circumstances for blockchain. This was a firsthand demonstration that policymakers are starting to know the intensive scope of what could be completed utilizing blockchain.
In parallel, developments on crypto coverage in the U.S. additionally got here in hoped-for however surprising selections from the courts.
Numerous federal judges — appointed by presidents from each events — confirmed a specific understanding of the nuances and variations introduced by the know-how and the manner the trade features. The Ripple, Grayscale and Uniswap courts all acknowledged a lot of the arguments round decentralization and self-custody that the trade has been making for years. In doing so, these courts confirmed that sure regulators’ positions actually attempt to match the crypto sq. peg into the TradFi spherical gap, with restricted outcomes.
The choice in Risley v. Uniswap Labs et al. is especially noteworthy for 2 causes. First, the choice dives deep into the know-how round decentralized finance. It acknowledges that software program builders innovating with new know-how can’t be responsible for the actions of unknown, unaffiliated third events who might have interaction in “bad acts” by way of the software program (a corollary to the selections in Napster and Grokster greater than 20 years in the past). Second, the choice acknowledged that we don’t know what crypto belongings are presently — “securities, commodities or something else.” Making that distinction is a call in Congress’ purview. This latter recognition can be noteworthy since the SEC’s case towards Coinbase, which hinges in massive half on whether or not “tokens are securities,” is earlier than the identical court docket.
Despite these developments, the trade doesn’t have the “regulatory clarity” for which it has been asking. In truth, the problem for 2024 is larger than ever: How can we work with regulators and policymakers globally to fight dangerous actors utilizing crypto for illicit means? This query, one which’s typically known as the AML (anti-money laundering) difficulty, is essential for crypto to not solely flourish, but additionally to outlive.
How the trade can and may deal with the query of AML requires its personal article (or articles!), however our problem on the regulatory entrance is evident. The trade should band collectively to offer viable options that talk to the regulatory objectives of detection and deterrence of dangerous actors.
Broader use circumstances now abound, however we have to make them extra helpful
It will come as no shock that I might dub 2023 “the Year of the Use Case.” It was a yr in which I used to be concerned in serving to launch an open, interactive web site, The Value Prop (thevalueprop.io), to showcase use circumstances for blockchain know-how throughout the world. This website aggregates novel blockchain-based purposes already in existence.
Think avatars on Reddit, digital footwear on Nike, or loyalty NFT reward packages with Starbucks. Think main manufacturers experimenting with what it appears to be like prefer to let go of complete management over loyalty packages and factors, as a substitute relinquishing these into the custody and possession of customers. The California DMV regarded into tokenizing automobile titles; there are experiments with placing land registration on-chain in Peru; and round half of Indian states have begun to include throughout completely different companies, together with police complaints.
Think tokenization of off-chain belongings in the monetary sector and past, the place JPMorgan, Franklin Templeton, BNY Mellon, Mirae Asset Securities, and plenty of others have already begun tokenizing belongings, with some estimates placing the quantity of complete tokenized belongings already at $3 billion. Projects like Courtyard and Regen Network permit for tokenization of belongings like Pokémon playing cards and carbon credit.
While the former group will permit our present monetary system to maneuver extra shortly and effectively, the latter will remodel who can take part in the financial system, and the way.
Across practically any vertical you possibly can think about, some factor of blockchain has begun to seem.
Although an increasing number of persons are interacting with some side of some blockchain daily, many with out even figuring out it, the problem now’s focusing the trade on use circumstances which are the most impactful, the most recreation altering. Builders have to maintain constructing, however in ways in which have highly effective enchantment. That means pondering past the long-standing narrative of “banking the unbanked,” which, for higher or for worse, is a narrative we now have moved past.
In order to make sure that adoption proliferates and the worth of this know-how is accepted, particularly in the face of very loud crypto pessimists (the doomers!), builders ought to lean into product-market match (PMF) that’s already robust with some crypto use circumstances, like stablecoins. Building and innovating on this success means pondering past previous narratives, with PMF in thoughts.
This will probably be a problem. So a lot of this area has been targeted on worth and quantity for a quantity of years, indicators of adoption.
This winter, I skipped the dinner events, opting to work and plan for some of the challenges mentioned above. The momentum of 2023 has led to a rising sense, even amongst buddies and acquaintances who don’t comply with the area intently, that the trade and I are okay, that crypto is right here to remain.
Regardless of the challenges the trade faces going into 2024, I’m as optimistic as ever: Those who’re nonetheless constructing are the greatest, most passionate individuals who will permit the trade — and this know-how — to achieve its full potential.